TAFT, CA, USA
N414RH
CESSNA 414
THE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICE (EMS/MEDEVAC) FLIGHT WAS DISPATCHED TO TRANSPORT A PATIENT IN RESPONSE TO A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. DURING ARRIVAL TO THE DESTINATION, THE PILOT CONTACTED THE AIRPORT UNICOM FOR ADVISORIES AND WAS ADVISED TO LAND ON RUNWAY 25. RUNWAY 25 HAD A 2.2 PERCENT UPHILL GRADE AND WAS RESTRICTED TO LANDINGS ONLY. AFTER LANDING, THE AIRPLANE WAS REFUELED AND THE PATIENT WAS PUT ON BOARD. THE PILOT BACK-TAXIED ON RUNWAY 25 AND PROCEEDED TO TAKEOFF UPHILL WITH THE AIRPLANE NEAR ITS MAXIMUM GROSS WEIGHT. ACCORDING TO GROUND WITNESSES, THERE WAS A TAILWIND, WHICH THEY ESTIMATED WAS BETWEEN 4 AND 15 KNOTS. THE TEMPERATURE WAS ABOUT 100 DEGREES, AND THE DENSITY ALTITUDE WAS ABOUT 3200 FEET. AFTER THE AIRPLANE BECAME AIRBORNE, THE PILOT STARTED AN IMMEDIATE LEFT TURN TO AVOID RISING TERRAIN. HOWEVER, THE LEFT TIP TANK CONTACTED THE GROUND, AND THE AIRPLANE CARTWHEELED. IT CAME TO REST ABOUT 711 FEET FROM THE DEPARTURE END OF THE RUNWAY. THE FLAPS AND LANDING GEAR WERE FOUND FULLY EXTENDED; THE PUBLISHED CONFIGURATION FOR TAKEOFF DATA IN THE FLIGHT MANUAL WAS FOR 'WING FLAPS - UP.' THE AIRPORT HAD NO SIGNS TO INDICATE RUNWAY USE RESTRICTIONS; HOWEVER, THE RESTRICTIONS WERE PUBLISHED IN THE AIRPORT FACILITY DIRECTORY.
HISTORY OF FLIGHT On July 19, 1994, about 1420 hours Pacific daylight time, a Cessna 414, N414RH, operated by Rogers Helicopters, Inc., of Clovis, California, was destroyed during takeoff at Taft, California. The flight was being conducted under the provisions of 14 CFR Part 135 of the Federal Aviation Regulations as an air medical flight that was in response to a medical emergency. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed. The patient being transported expired from injuries sustained in the accident about 10 hours after the accident. The pilot and two medical attendants received serious injuries. The flight had been dispatched from Fresno, California, to Taft, about 115 miles south, to transport the patient back to Fresno for hospitalization. According to the information obtained by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspector, the first takeoff at Fresno had been aborted when a nose baggage door came open. Prior to landing at Taft, the pilot called the UNICOM radio for landing advisories. The pilot was advised that runway 25 was being used for landing. Runway 25 has a 2.2 percent upslope with the far end about 100 feet higher than the approach end, and is restricted by the airport for landing only. After the patient was loaded on board the airplane, the pilot back-taxied on runway 07 to the beginning of runway 25. The pilot proceeded to depart uphill on runway 25. Ground witnesses reported that the winds were from the east at speeds variously estimated between 4 knots and 15 knots at the time of the takeoff attempt. The witnesses reported that after lift-off the aircraft climbed about 30 feet, then did not gain anymore altitude. Near the departure end of the runway, the aircraft banked left and the left wing tip fuel tank scraped the ground. The aircraft then cartwheeled. In the pilot's written statement, he said that prior to departure he estimated the winds were from the west at 10 to 15 knots. He assessed that with a tailwind of 10 to 15 knots, runway 07 would be too short to allow for possible engine failure on takeoff. He decided that, based on winds and accelerate to stop distance, it would be safer to depart on runway 25. PERSONNEL INFORMATION The pilot reported a total flight time of 10,000 hours; however, his total time in the accident aircraft make and model was unknown. Review of Rogers Helicopters company records revealed that the pilot had successfully completed an FAA competency flight check in accordance with 14 CFR 135.293 in the accident airplane on July 6, 1993. The pilot's rest and duty times were found to be within the requirements of 14 CFR 135. In an oral interview, the pilot reported that he had flown into the Taft airport one time in the previous year. AIRCRAFT INFORMATION The airplane had been modified in accordance with a Supplemental Type Certificate (STC) as a Riley conversion, with Lycoming IO- 720-B1BD 400 hp engines installed in place of the original equipment powerplants. Riley International was contacted by telephone. A company spokesperson stated that no performance data is supplied with the installation; however, flight tests established that the takeoff, climb, and single-engine performance were equal to or greater than the original Cessna design. The airplane was equipped with a neonatal pediatric respiratory unit mounted where seats No. 4 and 6 would normally be located. METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION There is no official weather reporting facility at the Taft Airport. Ground witnesses reported that the winds were from the east at estimates which ranged from 4 to 15 knots. According to a photograph taken by a newspaper, smoke from the postcrash fire was noted to be drifting towards the west. The temperature was about 100 degrees Fahrenheit and the density altitude was approximately 3200 feet. AIRPORT INFORMATION The Taft-Kern County airport is located on 71 acres of uneven terrain. According to the FAA Airport Master Record Form 5010-1, updated July 29, 1993, the airport has 2 runways, 03/21 and 07/25. Runways 21 and 25 are restricted to landings only. Runways 03 and 07 are for takeoff only. Runways 21 and 25 each have a 2.2 percent uphill grade. The airport is listed as a basic utility A-1 category airport, and is not required to comply with the signage requirements contained in FAA advisory circular 150/5340. The airport restrictions are reflected in the government publication, "Airport/Facility Directory", and other commercial airport flight information guides. Examination of the airport surface area did not find ground indicators or signage to indicate runway usage or restrictions. Airport advisories are available by a fixed-base operator on the UNICOM radio frequency 122.8 MHz; however, no full-time dedicated operator is available to monitor the UNICOM. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION Examination of the wreckage site revealed that the airplane came to rest about 711 feet south-southwest of the approach end of runway 07, as measured on the mean wreckage path of 210 degrees. Examination of a newly-paved aircraft tie-down area located along the south side of the runway 07 threshold and extended runway centerline to the west, revealed diagonal scrape marks on an approximate heading of 215 degrees. The start of the scrape marks were measured to be about 380 feet from the runway 25 centerline. Examination of the left wing tip fuel tank revealed similar scrape marks with remnants of asphalt. Further examination of the same area revealed near-parallel strike marks in the asphalt which were determined to be propeller blade marks. The marks started about 473 feet from the runway 25 centerline. The left propeller assembly was found separated from the left engine about 567 feet from the edge of the runway. Examination of the blades revealed chordwise striations, aft bending, and leading edge damage. The right propeller was still attached to the right engine. All propeller blades displayed similar blade damage as the left. An examination of the airplane was conducted at the accident site. Detailed disassembly and review of the following system actuators and valves revealed: 1) the landing gear was in the down-and-locked position; 2) the wing flaps were symmetrical and in the full-down position; 3) the right fuel selector was located on the right auxiliary tank, and the left fuel selector was located on the left main tank. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The airplane wreckage was released to the insurance company representative on July 20,1994.
THE PILOT'S INADEQUATE PREFLIGHT PLANNING/PREPARATION AND SELECTION OF THE WRONG RUNWAY FOR TAKEOFF. FACTORS RELATED TO THE ACCIDENT WERE: THE UPHILL SLOPE OF THE RUNWAY, TAILWIND, HIGH DENSITY ALTITUDE, AND FAILURE OF THE PILOT TO CORRECTLY CONFIGURE THE FLAPS FOR TAKEOFF.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
