FARMINGDALE, NY, USA
N3176G
Beech F33A
Witnesses saw the airplane take off from runway 14. According to them, the airplane went into a steep, nose high attitude, during the initial climb after lift-off, then it entered a spin, descended, and crashed. During an examination of the aircraft after the accident, the elevator trim was found in the full nose-up position. No mechanical malfunction was found during an examination of the main pitch servo and pitch trim servo. No preimpact mechanical failure of the airplane or engine was found. A toxicology test of the pilot's liver specimen showed 2.6 mg/kg Imipramine and 5.9 mg/kg Desipramine; these are antidepressants, which were not approved for use while operating an aircraft.
HISTORY OF FLIGHT On September 24, 1995, at 1705 eastern daylight time, a Beech F33A, N3176G, collided with the ground during takeoff at Republic Airport, in Farmingdale, New York. The certificated private pilot, the sole occupant, was fatally injured. The aircraft was destroyed. The aircraft was operated as a personal flight under 14 CFR Part 91. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time and a flight plan was not filed. The trip originated in Bedford, Massachusetts, on September 23. The accident occurred as the airplane departed Farmingdale, with an intended destination of Bedford, Massachusetts. There were several witnesses who saw the airplane takeoff and impact the ground west of runway 14. Witness statements are appended. One witness stated "...I viewed an aircraft in a vertical position on upwind leg for runway 14 at about 400 feet. At that point he continued beyond a vertical position... I heard a sound of full power being added (low to high). After that he started a spin straight down (1 1/2 rotations). The aircraft struck the ground in an extreme nose down attitude, folded on itself and exploded. The aircraft struck the ground with the cockpit facing me." The airplane impacted the ground 253 feet off the right side, and 5000 feet down the 6000 foot-long runway. The wreckage was oriented on a magnetic heading of 280 degrees and the forward section was destroyed by fire. PERSONNEL INFORMATION The pilot held a private pilot certificate with single engine land privileges and an instrument rating. According to the pilot's log book, he had logged more than 578 hours of flight time, including 146 hours in the accident make and model airplane. The pilot held a valid Third Class Medical Certificate, issued August 16, 1994. AIRCRAFT INFORMATION The 1988 Beech F33A airplane, serial no. CE-1271, was equipped with a Continental IO-520-BB engine, serial number 578396. According to the engine log book, the airplane had accumulated over 812 hours of flight time at the time of the most recent annual inspection, that was completed on October 6, 1994. METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION The 1645 eastern daylight time weather observation for Republic Airport, Farmingdale, New York, reported the following conditions: Sky condition, ceiling 2,000 feet broken; visibility, 30 miles; temperature, 67 degrees Fahrenheit (F); dew point, 47 degrees F; wind out of 100 degrees at 8 knots; and altimeter setting, 30.22 inches Hg. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION The airplane impacted the ground 253 feet off the right side, about 5,000 feet down the 6,000 foot-long runway. The wreckage was oriented on a magnetic heading of 280 degrees, and the forward section of the airplane was destroyed by fire. Both wings sustained fire damage. The left wing exhibited leading edge crush. Both wing flaps remained attached to their respective wings. The flap actuator was retracted. The main landing gear push rods were retracted. According to Beech these positions correspond to flaps up and gear up. The empennage remained intact. Both elevator trim tabs were found in the down position. The elevator trim actuator measured 2.00 inches. According to Beech this corresponds to 27 degrees tab down. The autopilot control head was in the off position. Further examination of the main pirch servo and pitch trim servo is described in the ADDITIONAL INFORMATION section of the narrative. The engine was located in a crater about 2 feet deep. All six cylinders remained secured to the crankcase. The propeller assembly had separated and was located in the crater. One of the propeller blades was twisted midspan, and exhibited evidence of chordwise scratching. Further examination of the engine revealed that the crankshaft propeller mounting flange was separated at the engine oil seal. The throttle, propeller and mixture controls were positioned full forward. The magnetos, engine starter, and some accessories separated. The magnetos did not rotate when turned by hand. The fuel pump was removed and the coupler drive was intact. The propeller governor sustained impact damage. The engine did not rotate when turned by hand. A postaccident engine teardown was conducted at Teledyne Continental Motors facility, in Mobile, Alabama. A summary of the teardown is located in the ADDITIONAL INFORMATION section of the narrative. MEDICAL/PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION A Medical Examination of the pilot was performed by Dr. Palutke, Medical Examiner of the Suffolk Medical Examiner's Office, Hauppauge, New York, on September 25, 1995. Toxicological examination was conducted for the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Aeronautical Center by the Department of Defense Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, in Washington, D. C. Toxicological test results were positive for drugs (antidepressants). The tests revealed the following: Imipramine was detected in the liver by gas chromatography and confirmed by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. The liver contained 2.6 mg/kg of imipramine as quantitated by gas chromatography. Desipramine was detected in the liver by gas chromatography and confirmed by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. The liver contained 5.9 mg/kg of desipramine as quantitated by gas chromatography. According to the 1995 Physician's Desk Reference (PDR), Imipramine is used to treat symptoms of depression. The PDR states that imipramine "...may impair the mental and/or physical abilities required for the performance of potentially hazardous tasks, such as operating an automobile or machinery..." ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Main Pitch Servo and Pitch Trim Servo Examination The main pitch servo and the pitch trim servo were removed from the wreckage and sent to Allied Signal Aerospace, in Olathe, Kansas. On March 26, 1996, a component examination and functional test were conducted under the supervision of the FAA. The examination revealed that the pitch servo had no visible impact damage. According to the Allied Signal investigator, the unit exhibited fire damage and corrosion due to fire suppressant chemical intrusion. The cover was removed and the unit was inspected prior to functional testing. The engage solenoid was in the disengaged position and the solenoid plunger moved freely. When powered, the solenoid engaged and disengaged normally. According to the Allied Signal investigator, the servo motor drives in both directions as commanded, and the servo speed was measured and found to be within specifications. He reported that the servo feedback tachometer had a bent shaft, which was straightened to allow engagement of the tachometer drive gear to the motor gear. He stated that the tachometer appeared to be functional. The Allied Signal investigator indicated that the autotrim sense switches were tested and found to be electrically non-functional, i.e. the switches could be activated mechanically, but electrical continuity was not measured in the activated (closed) position. He stated that the servo clutch was initially frozen. After breaking free the stuck clutch, the torque was measured at 15/17 inch pounds of torque. Specification is 16 +/-2 inch pounds for this application. The Allied Signal investigator reported that the pitch trim servo sustained fire damage and chemical corrosion damage, similar to the main pitch servo. The cover was removed and a visual inspection conducted. The investigator stated that the engage solenoid was in the disengaged position and the solenoid plunger moved freely. Power was applied to the unit, and the solenoid and the motor functioned normally in both the autotrim and manual electric trim modes. The manual electric trim regulator voltage was measured at 15.2 volts d.c. According to the manufacturer, the specification range for this servo part number is 14 to 17 volts d.c. The Allied Signal investigator reported that manual trim motor speed was measured at 2 RPM, which is correct for this application. The servo clutch was found to operate within its normal torque specifications. Engine Teardown/Examination The engine was shipped to the Teledyne Continental Motors (TCM) facility, in Mobile, Alabama. On February 22, 1996, an engine examination was conducted under the supervision of the FAA. According to the Product Analysis Manager from Continental, the engine sustained fire and impact damage. The crankcase exhibited impact damage on the right side. The crankshaft main bearings exhibited normal operational signatures. The engine crankshaft flange and the crankshaft propeller flange separated. The magnetos, fuel pump and fuel manifold were disassembled. According to the manufacturer's representative, all internal components appeared normal with the exception of fire and impact damages. The examination revealed normal operational signatures throughout the engine. The TCM representative stated that all internal components appeared lubricated. He reported that the teardown/examination did not disclose evidence of mechanical malfunction that would have precluded operation. See details of engine examination, attached. The wreckage was released to Kevin M. Olsen, of Olsen and Associates Inc., Insurance Claims Specialists on February 20, 1996.
failure of the pilot to maintain pitch control of the airplane during the initial climb after lift-off, which resulted in a steep climb, loss of airspeed, and a resultant stall/spin and subsequent crash. A factor relating to the accident was: failure of the pilot to properly set the elevator trim before takeoff.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
