EAGLE POINT, OR, USA
N278ML
Bellanca 8KCAB
The aerobatics flight instructor (first pilot) intentionally entered an inverted left spin (using left rudder) to demonstrate the maneuver to his student (second pilot). The instructor was unable to recover from the spin after about 5 or 6 rotations, so he asked the student to help him. The student stated that he applied full right rudder and noted that it was already in the full right travel position. The student also stated that the instructor was probably not 'on the controls' at the time, and that engine power was reduced at spin initiation and did not change. The instructor subsequently told the student to bail out, which he did successfully about 250 feet above the ground. The airplane, with the instructor still strapped in the rear seat, impacted the ground and was destroyed. An examination of the wreckage did not reveal any preimpact mechanical deficiencies. The rudder was found in the full left (left pedal) position at the accident site, and one propeller blade exhibited damage typical with some applied power at impact. The instructor had about 18 hours of total time in type, and had not flown during the previous 30 days. The airplane was 52 pounds over gross weight at the time of accident.
HISTORY OF FLIGHT On December 14, 1996, about 1520 Pacific standard time, N278ML, a Bellanca 8KCAB Super Decathlon, operated by Skinner Aviation, Inc., Ashland, Oregon, impacted terrain during an uncontrolled descent near Eagle Point, Oregon, and was destroyed. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed and no flight plan had been filed. The certified flight instructor (CFI) was fatally injured. The student, who was a commercial pilot receiving aerobatic instruction at the time of the accident, bailed out of the airplane and suffered minor injuries. The local flight departed from Ashland about 1500 and was conducted under 14 CFR 91. The second pilot (surviving pilot), stated (statement attached) that he wanted to perform aerobatics in a Decathlon, so he scheduled himself to fly aerobatics through Skinner Aviation about one week prior to the accident. That flight was canceled due to weather, so he had rescheduled for the day of the accident. The second pilot arrived at the Ashland Airport and met the first pilot (CFI) for the first time. The second pilot stated that he and the CFI sat down and underwent a "thorough" preflight briefing for a "spin series, ailerons rolls, and loops" that lasted from 30 to 45 minutes. The second pilot stated that the airplane was then fueled, and there were about 10 gallons in each wing after the fueling. The airplane then underwent a "thorough" preflight inspection with no problems noted. The second pilot stated that the CFI appeared to be feeling well. During the preflight inspection, the CFI demonstrated the use of the parachute to the second pilot. The second pilot stated that he attributes the parachute briefing to the saving of his life. The second pilot started the airplane "with a little trouble" because he "was not used to a fuel injected engine." The airplane was then taxied. The second pilot stated that he felt the airplane was "not very responsive taxiing on the ground" because of the gear, but no other problems were noted. The second pilot stated that the engine "ran fine" during the run-up and takeoff. The second pilot climbed to 6,500 feet, while performing Dutch rolls. After some clearing turns, the CFI asked the second pilot if he wanted to do some spins. The second pilot performed three upright spins; two spins with power off (one to the left and one to the right) and one spin with power on (to the left). He "recovered fine" from all three spins. The CFI then took control of the airplane to demonstrate an inverted spin, according to the second pilot. The CFI climbed to 7,200 feet, rolled inverted, and maintained inverted flight "for quite a while," heading northeast (south of the accident site). The second pilot stated that the CFI then "pitched the nose up and put it in a gradual inverted climb". The airplane stalled and the CFI added left rudder. The airplane "rolled upright" into an inverted spin, and it was a "normal spin entry." After the third revolution, the second pilot began to think that the CFI "fouled up the recovery." The rate of the spin began to accelerate through the first three revolutions, then the "rate slowed," and the second pilot thought the CFI was going to recover. The rate then began to accelerate again and continued to make a few more revolutions for a total of five or six. The CFI then stated to the second pilot: "Help me with the rudder." The airplane was spinning to the left (as viewed inside the airplane) at the time. The second pilot "hit the right rudder" and noted that it was "against the stops." He then began to press on the left rudder pedal, at which time the CFI stated: "not that rudder." The second pilot then pressed back on the right rudder again, which was at its full forward stop. The second pilot stated that the CFI had "pulled power off" when he first entered the inverted spin, and the second pilot did not perceive any addition or reduction of engine power again. During the spin, the second pilot also "took a hold of the stick" which was resting in the forward position, and "pulled back about 3 to 4 inches." He stated that there was "no pressure against the elevators," and it was like the airplane was "sitting on the ground," and that he did not think that the CFI was "on the controls." He released the stick and it went forward again. The airplane was headed "nose down" during the spin. The second pilot's foot was on the right rudder. The airplane made another revolution. The CFI then yelled to the second pilot to "bail out." The second pilot pulled the cabin door handle and jettisoned the door. He then unbuckled his harness and "rolled onto the wing." He remembered that the airplane was "in a fairly flat attitude" at this time, with little wind force. He still had his headset on and "stayed on the wing a little while." He then remembered his parachute deploying, and he stated that he "wasn't very high" at the time. He also stated that the wind was out of the north about 15 knots. The second pilot remembered hearing the airplane impacting the ground, but he did not recall seeing it crash, nor did he recall the timing of the crash noise. He stated that he did not perceive any problems with the engine during the flight, nor did he report any mechanical malfunctions with the airplane. According to an eyewitness (statement attached) who was traveling in a car along a highway at the time of the accident, the airplane was "going down in a corkscrew effect - kind of flat." The witness stated that the airplane was "nose down, then flattened, like in a spin" as it fell "straight down" toward the ground. She stated that the airplane was about 500 feet above the ground when she first spotted it, and that she saw two pieces of the airplane falling with it. She stated that one piece was larger than the other piece. She saw the airplane for "about 15 to 20 seconds in the sky" until it disappeared from her view. The airplane wreckage was located in hilly terrain 15 nautical miles from the departure airport at an elevation of about 1,500 feet msl. The accident occurred during the hours of daylight at the following coordinates: 42 degrees, 26.31 minutes North and 122 degrees, 38.10 minutes West. AIRCRAFT INFORMATION The aircraft, a 1977 Bellanca model 8KCAB "Super Decathlon," was designed as a tandem-seated, wood/fabric, high-wing, single-engine, aerobatic airplane. The aircraft had been recently purchased by the first pilot about three months prior to the accident. The pilot then leased the aircraft back to the operator. An examination of the airplane's maintenance logbooks did not reveal any unresolved discrepancies. The airplane had received an annual inspection on February 21, 1996. It had accumulated about 3,064 total flight hours at the time of the accident. Its engine, a Lycoming model AEIO-360-HIA, had been overhauled 184 operating hours prior to the accident. The Safety Board examined the most recent weight and balance records (attached) of the airplane. By utilizing the data from these records, documented weights of both pilots, and estimated fuel weights and fuel consumption rates, the Safety Board computed the estimated weight and balance at takeoff and during the time of the accident. The computations (attached) revealed that the airplane had exceeded its published maximum gross weight by 88 pounds at takeoff, and 52 pounds at the time of the accident. The computations also revealed that the moment of the airplane loading during the accident were within the extrapolated center of gravity envelope for the overgross condition. According to Bellanca Pilot's Operating Manual for the aircraft (excerpts attached): It is the pilot's responsibility to insure that the aircraft is loaded properly and within the weight and balance limitations. All flight performance, procedures and characteristics are based on this prerequisite. If the aircraft is to be used for aerobatic flight, it must be loaded within the flight envelope. The manual also provides procedures to initiate and recover from an inverted spin. The manual states: Enter from inverted stall power off with full forward stick and full rudder in the direction of desired spin. Maintain with full pro spin controls until 1/4 to 1/2 turn prior to recovery heading. Recover with positive movement of stick to neutral position and full opposite rudder. Hold pro-recovery controls until rotation stops and positive control and flying speed is restored. Then neutralize rudder and smoothly recover from dive to level flight. Free release of controls is not adequate for spin recovery. Positive movement of the controls by the pilot is required. PERSONNEL INFORMATION The first pilot, a 30-year-old male, was a certificated commercial pilot with ratings for instrument single and multiengine land airplanes. He was also a CFI with ratings in instrument, single-engine, and multiengine airplanes. According to FAA records, the pilot was issued an FAA Second Class Medical Certificate on July 12, 1996, with no restrictions or limitations. The Safety Board was unable to recover the pilot's personal flight log books; however, the pilot reported that he had accumulated 1,225 hours of total flight experience at the time of his most recent FAA medical application on July 12, 1996. According to the operator and an airplane flight log sheet found in the wreckage, the pilot had logged a total of 19.3 hours of flight time in type, including 6.3 total flight hours during the previous 90 days of the accident, and no hours during the previous 30 days of the accident. The second pilot (surviving pilot), a 35-year-old business man, was a certificated commercial pilot with rating in single-engine land airplanes. According to FAA records, the pilot was issued an FAA Second Class Medical Certificate on April 26, 1996, with no restrictions or limitations. The second pilot reported that he had accumulated 600 hours of total flight experience at the time of his most recent FAA medical application on April 26, 1996. He stated that he had accumulated about 4 to 6 hours of aerobatic flight time in a Decathlon in 1990, and about 2 hours in a Pitts aerobatic airplane in 1996. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION The airplane wreckage was examined at the accident site on the morning after the accident. The wreckage was found inverted and in one piece. Only the propeller, exit door, and some pieces of Plexiglas had separated from the airplane. No evidence of fire, explosion, or in-flight structural failure was found. The second pilot's parachute was found about 50 feet from the wreckage. The CFI was found strapped into the rear seat of the airplane. A 1-foot-deep ground scar in soft dirt containing the separated propeller was found about 3 feet in front of, and to the north of the nose of the airplane. All primary and secondary flight control surfaces were accounted for at the accident site and were intact on the airplane. The airplane's skin was cut open by investigators to allow views of all flight control hardware. No evidence was found to indicate a flight control deficiency or malfunction. Flight control cable continuity was verified for all flight control surfaces. An examination of the left wing revealed aft "accordion" crush damage on its leading edge beginning a point about 5 feet from its tip and continuing to the tip. The crush damage was oriented along a direction moving from the top of the wing and curling over to its underside. The wing was found inverted and its lift struts had broken off at the fuselage. The underside wing attachments of the lift struts remained attached. An examination of the right wing also revealed aft "accordion" crush damage on its leading edge. The right wing tip was relatively undamaged in comparison with the left wing. The wing was found inverted and its lift struts were secured at both ends. The entire empennage remained attached to the airframe and was inverted. An examination of the rudder/vertical stabilizer revealed that it was imbedded into the ground and the rudder was deflected to the left (left rudder pedal position) at maximum travel . An examination of the cockpit controls and instrument panel revealed the following: The engine tachometer read 1,300 revolutions per minute. The mixture control was in the full rich position. The rear (first pilot) throttle position was found damaged and was open about two-thirds of its travel. No obstructions were found at the bases of both control sticks. The engine underwent an external examination and detailed inspection at the accident site; the inspection did not reveal evidence of any preimpact mechanical malfunctions. Evidence of fuel was found in the inlet and outlet fuel lines of the fuel servo valve. The two-bladed Hartzell controllable propeller had separated from the engine and was found about 3 feet from it. Oil was found inside the hub. Blade no. 1 was secure in the hub and was relatively straight, intact, clean, and undamaged as compared to Blade no. 2. Blade no. 2 was found imbedded into the ground and was also secured in the hub. It exhibited slight "S" bending at its mid-section and near its tip. Blade no. 2 also had exhibited chordwise scratching on its outboard half, and a piece of the blade tip had been sheered off in forward twisting. MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION An autopsy was performed on the first pilot in Medford, Oregon, by Dr. James N. Olson, M.D., Deputy State Medical Examiner for Jacksonville County, Oregon , on December 16, 1996. The cause of death was listed as "Massive craniofacial, neck thoracic, abdominal and bilateral upper and lower extremity injuries due to single engine fixed wing aircraft crash, pilot." A toxicological analysis was ordered and performed on specimens taken from the pilot by the FAA Civil Aeromedical Institute in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma. According to their report (attached), results were negative for carbon monoxide, cyanide, alcohol. An unspecified amount of the drug Meconin was found in the pilot's urine, but none in the blood sample. No evidence of pilot impairment at the time of the accident was found. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The aircraft wreckage was released to Mr. James V. Stiger, Bellevue, Washington, on December 20, 1996. Mr. Stiger was representing the operator of the airplane at the time of the release.
The failure of the first pilot (flight instructor) to initiate proper aircraft control, and his failure to perform the adequate remedial action to recover from an intentional inverted spin.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
