Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
N98WG
Grote Cruiser TR-4
The flight was cleared for a straight-in approach to runway 9R, from about 10 miles west of the airport, and the pilot was told to report 1 mile out. On the first approach the pilot started to go around just before the arrival end of the runway threshold. The pilot was cleared by the ATC Tower, for "right traffic," and return for a landing on runway 9R. On the second attempted landing witnesses saw the airplane touchdown past midfield and abort the landing. The airplane stayed low to the ground just above the trees, made a left turn toward the north, and started descending behind the trees. The airplane impacted with power lines about 100 feet above the ground and came to rest in the front yard of a private residence about 1 mile east of the airport. There was no post crash fire nor was there any evidence found to indicate a fire in the engine assembly. The examination of the engine assembly and the testing of the fuel pump, throttle/fuel metering unit, and the 6-fuel injector nozzles, revealed no discrepancies.
On April 18, 2002, about 0815 eastern daylight time, a Grote Cruiser TR-4 homebuilt airplane, N98WG, registered to an individual, struck power lines while attempting a go-around at the North Perry Airport, Florida, and impacted in a residential area of Pembroke Pines, Florida. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time. No flight plan was filed for the 14 CFR Part 91 personal flight. The airplane was destroyed. The private-rated pilot received fatal injuries, and there were no reported injuries to anyone on the ground. The flight had departed Kendall, Florida, en route to Pembroke Pines, about 0715. According to the FAA controller at the air traffic control tower (ATCT) at the North Perry Airport, the flight was cleared for a straight-in approach to runway 9R, from about 10 miles west of the airport. At 0800, the pilot of N98WG called the North Perry Tower four different times. The Tower controller answered him each time, asking the pilot how he heard the tower. At 0803:20, the pilot answered "…loud and clear." The pilot was cleared for a straight-in approach to runway 9R, and to report 1 mile out. The pilot was asked by the controller, if he copied "…all of the...previous transmissions," and the pilot answered, "ok 98WG...niner right." At 0809:14, on the first approach the pilot started to go around just before the arrival end of the runway threshold. The pilot was cleared by the ATCT, for "right traffic," and return for a landing on runway 9R. On the second attempted landing he was cleared to land at 0811:46 and the pilot acknowledged the clearance. This was the last radio transmission. According to the FAA, Air Traffic Control Specialist, Local Controller's personnel statement, he cleared the pilot the second time to land on base leg for runway 9R. The controller said the airplane "touched down past midfield than aborted his landing." The airplane "stayed low to the ground. He than made a "left turn" toward the north, and "started descending behind the trees." The FAA, Air Traffic Control Specialist, Ground Controller's personnel statement, said about the same thing as the local controller except the ground controller said, that past midfield the airplane "lifted off," and was "low just above the trees." The airplane then turned "left like he was going to try and land on the road east of the field." According to witnesses the airplane did not climb very high, and it appeared that it would not clear the trees at the end of the airport property. The airplane was at a low altitude when it turned left (north). At this point some of the witnesses saw smoke coming from the engine. While heading north at a low altitude the airplane struck power lines, fell to the ground, and impacted on the front lawn of a private residence. A certified flight instructor, who witnessed the accident, while standing at the airport, said, the airplane "stayed low...approximately 20 feet off the ground...in ground effect" until well after "D" taxiway, and then tried to climb. She said the airplane "did not get a very good climb." She remembered saying to herself, "…this guy needs to get up over those trees or he's going to crash." She "heard power," but felt that the engine was "not a good running engine," because the airplane "barley" made it over the trees. In addition, she said as he turned left, " black stream of smoke sank down" from the airplane. She said for a "brief second" there was that black smoke, and then nothing. For an instant, there was a "grayish tuft of smoke, dirt, etc, and than silence." She said that the turn he made before the crash was about 45 degrees to the north from the departure runway. The airplane impacted with power lines about 100 feet above the ground and came to rest in the front yard of a private residence about 1 mile east of the airport. There was no post crash fire. A captain from the Pembroke Pines' Fire Department said that when he arrived at the crash scene about 20 gallons of fuel had come out of the left wing. When the FAA inspector arrived he found only a trace of fuel in the right tank and the fuel selector was selected to the right tank position. However, the fire captain wrote a statement that the fuel selector "was in the left position" upon his arrival at the crash site, and it was his personnel that moved to the "RIGHT" tank. A piece of cable from the power line was found imbedded into the left wing. The wreckage was removed from the crash site and taken to the Fort Lauderdale Executive for a more detailed examination. On May 7, 2002, the engine from N98WG, was examined under the supervision of the NTSB. The external examination of the engine revealed that the propeller flange had broken off the crankshaft. The engine mounts, and the number 1 intake pipe were broken. Before attempting to rotate the engine the fuel pump was removed. The fuel pump rotated freely by hand and the pump drive shaft was found intact. Fuel was found in all the fuel lines, the fuel pump, gascolator, and the fuel manifold valve. The fuel manifold valve screen and gascolator were found clean. A sample of fuel was tested for water using water finding paste, and no water was found. The electric boost pump was tested by applying electrical current to the pump, the pump operated without discrepancies. Both suction and pressure were noted. The engine was rotated by hand, and finger compression was noted on all the cylinders. Valve action was noted on all cylinders and continuity was noted throughout the engine. There was no evidence found to indicate a fire in the engine assembly. All the cylinders were removed from the engine and an internal inspection was performed. Examination of the pistons, pins, piston rings, and internal components revealed no breakage, no abnormal wear, or any other discrepancies. Oil was present on all internal engine surfaces, and about 6 quarts of oil was drained from the engine. No metal particles were noted in the oil. The oil filter was cut open and was found free of contaminants. Both magnetos were rotated by hand, and both produced spark. The spark plugs were removed and no discrepancies were found. The top plugs were covered with oil, but fire department personnel said that they had to invert the engine during the rescue efforts. The fuel pump, throttle/fuel metering unit, and 6-fuel injector nozzles were removed from the engine and shipped to Teledyne Continental Motor's facilities in Mobile, Alabama, where they were flow bench tested, under the supervision of Paul Cox, NTSB Air Safety Investigator, Northeast Regional Office, Parsippany, New Jersey, on June 18, 2002. Other than a cracked housing at the fuel inlet fitting, all components flowed near factory specifications (See the copy of the TCM Flow Test Report, an attachment to this report). Dr. Lance G. Davis performed an autopsy on the pilot, at the Medical Examiners Office, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, on May 1, 2002. According to the autopsy report the cause of death was "…Blunt Trauma...." No findings, which could be considered causal to the accident, were reported. Toxicological tests were conducted at the Federal Aviation Administration, Research Laboratory, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, and revealed, "No ethanol detected in Urine." The drug Acetaminophen 19.7 (ug/ml, ug/g) was found in the urine. Acetaminophen is an over-the-counter painkiller often known by the trade name Tylenol. It would not be expected to result in any impairment, and was not found in the blood. (See the Federal Aviation Administration's Toxicology Report, an attachment to this report). The airplane was released to Mr. Larry Addison, Air and Sea Recovery Inc., on behalf of the owner's insurance company, on May 7, 2002. The fuel pump, throttle/fuel metering unit, and 6-fuel injector nozzles were released to Mr. Steve Smalley, of Air and Sea Recovery Inc., on behalf of the owner's insurance company, on September 4, 2002.
the pilot-in-command delayed initiating a go-around and failed to obtain sufficient altitude to clear obstacles at the departure end of the airport which resulted in an in-flight collision with power lines.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
