Oxnard, CA, USA
N53879
Bellanca 7ECA
The airplane ground looped during the landing roll. After touchdown, the pilot applied right rudder and the pedal became stuck in a near full forward position. The pilot was then unable to maintain directional control and the airplane turned approximately 270 degrees on the runway and came to rest. A post accident inspection revealed that the pin that secured the right rudder pedal to the brake cylinder arm was missing. There was also evidence of aluminum shavings at the pin attachment point. An identical problem was discovered by the operator on the sister ship to the accident airplane. The pin on the sister ship was changed a few weeks before the accident. The operator intended to examine the rudder pedal pins on the accident airplane in the next scheduled maintenance period. The manufacturer of the airplane indicated that the pin can be installed either outboard or inboard of the cotter key. As depicted in Figure 26 of the Parts Manual, the installation of the pin is depicted as inboard of the cotter key. In this model of the airplane, the battery is located in the forward section of the fuselage and a structural angle brace is installed for support. On the right pedal of the forward seat, the clearance between the pin and the angle brace is reduced with the angle brace in the design location if the pin is installed inboard of the cotter key. If the pin is installed outboard of the cotter key, it allows for greater clearance between the pin and the angle brace.
On December 27, 2003, at 0924 Pacific standard time, a Bellanca 7ECA, N53879, ground looped while landing on runway 7 at the Oxnard, California, airport. The airplane was owned and operated by CP Aviation, Inc., Santa Paula, California, and rented by the pilot for a local personal flight. The airplane sustained substantial damage. The private pilot, the sole occupant, was not injured. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time and no flight plan was filed. The airplane departed Santa Paula at 0842 for a flight to Oxnard. In a written statement, the pilot reported that he took off from Santa Paula and flew to Oxnard to practice takeoffs and landings. After several successful landings and takeoffs, the pilot touched down on runway 7 and the right rudder pedal bent top down and became stuck. As a result, he was unable to maintain directional control and the aircraft ground looped off the left side of the runway. The right horizontal stabilizer was damaged during the event. The pilot stated that the clevis pin that secured the right rudder pedal to the brake cylinder arm was missing, which prevented the application of right rudder. The Oxnard airport operations officer was interviewed via telephone by the National Transporation Safety Board investigator-in-charge (IIC). He noted that there was significant right horizontal stabilizer damage. The right pant wheel was "torn off and smashed up." It appeared that the pilot was unable to maintain directional control due to the right rudder pedal clevis pin missing. He also saw evidence of aluminum shavings at the clevis pin attachment point. A Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) airworthiness inspector interviewed the aircraft operator. The operator told the FAA inspector that this airplane, and another of the same make, model, and year, is used heavily for aerobatic instruction. In the past, they have had problems with the rudder pedal pin coming in contact with a structural fuselage angle brace during full extension of the rudder pedals in aerobatic maneuvers. This contact between the pin and the angle brace progressively wears/grinds the pin down to the point where it is no longer retained in the hole and comes out. This problem was found on the sister ship to the accident airplane a few weeks before the accident and that pin was changed. The operator intended to examine the rudder pedal pins on the accident airplane in the next scheduled maintenance period. The manufacturer of the airplane, Champion Aircraft, Inc., was contacted regarding the installation of the pin. In the Citabria Parts Manual, Figure 26 (Installation Brake System-Toe) indicates that the head of the cotter key is installed with the pin inboard of the cotter key. In this model of Citabria, the battery is located in the forward section of the airplane and a fuselage angle brace is installed for support. On the right pedal of the forward seat, the clearance between the pin and the angle brace is reduced. If the pin is installed outboard of the cotter key, there is a greater clearance between the angle brace and the pin. The manufacturer indicated that the pin could be installed either way; however, Figure 26 depicted the pin as being installed inboard of the cotter key.
the failure of the pin that secured the right rudder pedal to the brake cylinder arm due to improper installation of the pin. Also causal was the manufacturer's confusing maintenance instructions regarding the installation of the right rudder pedal pin and cotter key.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
