Clayton, NC, USA
N8844H
North American Navion
The instrument rated pilot who had not logged any actual instrument flight time did not obtain any preflight weather briefing with either Lockheed Martin FSS or DUATS. Instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) due to low ceilings and visibility were forecast to exist between the departure airport and the crash site location, though VFR conditions existed at the destination airport at both the departure time and estimated time of arrival. The flight departed under VFR, and proceeded in a northeasterly direction to a point approximately 59 nautical miles north-northeast from the departure airport where it was identified on radar. The flight was observed on radar for 55 nautical miles, and never flew higher than 800 feet pressure altitude. The flight continued in a northeasterly direction gradually descending while the terrain elevation gradually increased. A ceiling of broken clouds at 400 feet above ground level (agl) was noted at an airport 21 nautical miles from the crash site. For the last 9 minutes 31 seconds of the flight, the ground speed never decreased less than 110 knots. The airplane descended to 265 feet agl, and at the last radar return, which was located 0.18 nautical miles from the crash site, the ground speed was 130 knots. While approaching an antenna tower and water tower which were ahead of the flight path and 215 and 185 feet agl, respectively, the pilot banked hard to the right, and with the engine operating at approximately 2,300 rpm, the airplane impacted the parking lot of a restaurant. The airplane crashed into the restaurant, and was fragmented. A fire erupted at impact and the restaurant sustained impact and fire damage. Examination of the airframe, flight controls, engine, engine accessories, and propeller revealed no evidence of preimpact failure or malfunction.
HISTORY OF FLIGHT On September 21, 2007, about 1010 eastern daylight time, a North American Navion, N8844H, registered to and operated by a private individual, crashed into a restaurant located in Clayton, North Carolina. Instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) prevailed at the time and no flight plan was filed for the 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 91 personal flight from Conway-Horry County Airport (HYW), Conway, South Carolina, to Culpeper Regional Airport (CJR), Culpeper, Virginia. The airplane was destroyed by impact and a postcrash fire, and the private-certificated pilot, the sole occupant, was fatally injured. The restaurant was damaged by impact and fire; only one restaurant employee reported smoke inhalation. The flight originated about 0916, from HYW. The flight departed under visual flight rules (VFR), and the pilot did not establish contact with any air traffic control facility in-flight. A discrete transponder code was not assigned to the flight. Recorded radar data from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Raleigh, North Carolina, Air Route Surveillance Radar (ARSR) was analyzed by personnel from the Safety Board's Office of Research and Engineering, and is contained in a report titled "Recorded Radar and Performance Study." Radar returns associated with transponder code 1200 were tracked from a point beginning about 59 nautical miles north-northeast of the departure airport, and continue to a point located within 0.18 nautical miles of the accident site location at the approximate time of the accident. The radar data reflects that the flight was tracked for 55 nautical miles and never flew higher than 800 feet pressure altitude. The study further indicated the flight proceeded in a northeasterly direction, and gradually descended while the terrain elevation increased. The airplane descended to 265 feet above ground level (agl), and was flying in a north-northeasterly direction towards two obstacles which were located northeast and north of the accident site. The first obstacle in the line of flight was an antenna tower which is 215 feet agl, and the second obstacle was a water tower which is 185 feet agl. The plot depicts the airplane turning to the north when the flight was 1.15 nautical miles from antenna tower, then continuing for about 20 seconds. The last uncorrelated radar return was at 1010:31; the airplane at that time was at 265 feet agl. Between 1001, and the last uncorrelated radar return, the smoothed ground speed never decreased less than 110 knots. The ground speed at the last radar return was 130 knots. One witness who was inside on the second floor of a building located approximately 829 feet north-northeast of the crash site reported first hearing a sputtering/loud sound. He looked out of an adjacent window and observed the airplane following Highway 70 East. The wings were level but the airplane was descending. The airplane suddenly/abruptly banked to the right, and at that time the engine sound increased, but still did not sound correct. The witness further reported the airplane impacted the building nearly inverted. The sound he associated with the engine was similar to the sound of a semi tractor-trailer with the jake brake on. Another witness who had just dropped off his wife at the restaurant, and was driving westbound on Highway 70 near the restaurant, reported hearing a low-flying airplane. He looked towards the restaurant and noticed an airplane emerge from the clouds. The airplane was flying between 80 and 100 feet above ground level, and was located west of the restaurant flying in a 45-degree right bank. The airplane continued in the right bank which increased when the airplane was closer to nearby power lines. The airplane then rolled into a wings level position, and began descending like it was landing. He thought the airplane was trying to land on Highway 70 in the eastbound lanes, or in a lot adjacent to the restaurant. The airplane flew over the power lines, and impacted the parking lot causing the right wing to separate. The airplane then slid into the restaurant where the left wing hit the building. The witness further reported the engine did not sound like it was running wide open, but the engine sound was constant. There was no sputtering, and he could not recall the position of the landing gear. The airplane crashed into the restaurant during daylight hours. PERSONNEL INFORMATION The pilot, age 54, held a FAA private pilot certificate with ratings for airplane single engine land and instrument airplane, last issued on October 26, 2005. He held a FAA third class medical certificate issued on June 22, 2007, with the limitation that he, "Must wear corrective lenses[.] Not valid for any class after June 30, 2008." NTSB review of the pilot's logbook which begin with his first logged flight on March 5, 1988, and ends with a logged flight of an unrecorded date on or after July 20, 2007, revealed he logged a total time of 354.3 hours, of which 332.0 hours were as pilot-in-command. Since obtaining his instrument rating in October 2005, he logged 8.5 simulated instrument hours during three separate flights; however, he did not log any time in actual instrument conditions. His last logged simulated instrument flight occurred in 2007, but the month was not determined. During the previous 90 days he logged a total time of 4.0 hours. AIRCRAFT INFORMATION The airplane was manufactured by North American Aviation, Inc., on March 4, 1947, as model Navion, and designated serial number NAV-4-844. It was certificated in the normal and utility categories, and powered by a Teledyne IO-520-BB 285 horsepower engine and equipped with a 3-bladed constant speed McCauley D3A32C90-R propeller. The engine and propeller were installed in accordance with the optional engines and propellers listed in the airplane type certificate data sheet. NTSB review of copies of provided logbook entries revealed the airplane was last inspected in accordance with an annual inspection on July 20, 2007. The airplane total time and engine time since major overhaul at that time were 4,184.4 and 275 hours, respectively. The altimeter, static system, and transponder were last checked on April 1, 2005, in accordance with 14 CFR Part 91.411 Appendix E and 14 CFR Part 91.413 Appendix F. The permanent maintenance records were not located; however, a pouch containing several FAA 337 forms, several registration certificates, and the airworthiness certificate were located in the wreckage. METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION The pilot did not obtain a preflight weather briefing from either Lockheed Martin (LM) Flight Service Station (FSS) or either of the two Direct User Access Terminal System (DUATS) vendors, which are Data Transformation Corporation (DTC), and Computer Services Corporation (CSC). Additionally, there was no record of any in-flight contact by the pilot with any FAA air traffic control (ATC) or LM FSS facilities. On the day of the accident at 0715 local, or approximately 2 hours 1 minute before the flight departed, an Airman's Meteorological Information (AIRMET) for instrument flight rules (IFR) conditions was issued by the National Weather Service (NWS) forecasting ceilings below 1,000 feet and visibility below 3 miles in mist / fog. The AIRMET was valid until 1100 hours local, and the boundary encompassed by the AIRMET included the departure airport and accident site location. At the time of departure, a 500 foot ceiling with 10 miles visibility existed at an airport near the departure airport, and IMC conditions (1/2 mile visibility and 200 foot overcast ceiling) prevailed at Raleigh-Durham International Airport (RDU), which was located slightly west (approximately 11 nautical miles) of a straight line course drawn from the departure to destination airports. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the destination airport at the time of departure and also at the estimated time of arrival. A surface observation weather report at RDU taken at 1005, or approximately 5 minutes before the accident, indicated a broken ceiling existed at 400 feet, and the visibility was 1 mile. The RDU airport was located approximately 22 nautical miles northwest from the accident site. COMMUNICATIONS The pilot did not contact any FAA air traffic control facility during the accident flight. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION The airplane crashed into the parking lot then a restaurant located at 10365 US Highway 70 West, in Clayton, North Carolina, or on the south side of the eastbound lanes of Highway 70. The accident site was located approximately 25 degrees and 113 nautical miles from the departure airport. The restaurant was damaged by impact and fire. The exterior surface of the building exhibited impact marks consistent in size and shape with contact by components of the propeller. Examination of the accident site revealed the airplane impacted the parking lot while on a magnetic heading of 200 degrees, then impacted the front side of the restaurant approximately 104 feet 9 inches from the first of five parallel ground scars associated with propeller contact. The airplane traveled into the restaurant 33 feet 5 inches and came to rest inverted. The wreckage in the restaurant consisted of the fuselage / empennage with inboard sections of both wings, the separated engine, and components of the impact damaged propeller. Aircraft debris was located along the energy path in the parking lot, adjacent to the front side of the restaurant, and one propeller blade was found 279 feet from where the wreckage came to rest. Fire damage to the wreckage in the restaurant was noted. Further examination of the accident site revealed no damage to 40 foot-tall power lines that were located 133 feet 8 inches from the propeller ground scars, nor was there any damage to a nearby tree or light pole in the parking lot. The distance between the centers of the first and second propeller ground scars measured 22.5 inches. All identifiable airplane components were recovered for further examination. Examination of the wreckage following recovery revealed the entire airplane was fragmented and / or heat damaged. All components necessary to sustain flight, and all flight control surfaces were accounted for. Flight control cable continuity was confirmed for yaw, while tension overload of the elevator and aileron flight control cables was noted. The flaps were retracted, and the pitch trim was found at 10 degrees tab trailing edge down (nose-up). The cockpit, cabin, and inboard sections of both wings were destroyed by the postcrash fire. All fuel tanks were breached and /or fire damaged; no fuel was located in the tanks. The fuel selector was found positioned to the main tank position. Examination of the engine following recovery revealed crankshaft, and camshaft continuity. Impact damage to the engine precluded rotation of it. The upper portions of the Nos. 1, 3, and 5 cylinders were impact separated. Examination of the power section, lubrication, ignition, fuel metering, and air induction systems of the engine revealed no evidence of preimpact failure or malfunction. Examination of the propeller revealed the propeller hub was fractured and all propeller blades were separated from the hub. Additionally, the propeller piston, cylinder, and all pitch change components were impact separated. Examination of the propeller blades revealed all exhibited torsional twisting and heavy chordwise scratches on the cambered side of each blade. MEDICAL AND PATHOLOGICAL INFORMATION A postmortem examination of the pilot was performed by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, Chapel Hill, North Carolina. The cause of death was listed as "multiple blunt force traumatic injuries." Forensic toxicology was performed on specimens of the pilot by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Bioaeronautical Sciences Research Laboratory, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, and also by Office of the Chief Medical Examiner (M.E.'s Office). The result of analysis by the FAA was negative for carbon monoxide, cyanide, volatiles, and tested drugs. The result of analysis by the M.E.'s Office was negative for volatiles (ethanol). TESTS AND RESEARCH Circuit boards located in the wreckage were identified as being from a J.P. Instruments "Fuel Scan 450" instrument. The circuit boards were retained, but a representative of the manufacturer reported the circuit boards do not retain any data. The airplane was fueled on the morning of the accident at the departure airport. A total of 28.0 gallons of 100 low lead (100LL) fuel were added. The individual who performed the fueling stated each main fuel tank and the lower auxiliary fuel tank were filled as requested by the pilot. A calculation was performed by NTSB to determine engine rpm at the moment of ground contact. The calculation included the measured distance between the first and second propeller ground scars (22.5 inches), the last known ground speed (130 knots), and the number of propeller blades (3). The result was determined to be 2,334 rpm.
The pilot's intentional abrupt maneuver during low altitude cruise flight to avoid obstructions ahead, resulting in an in-flight collision with terrain and a building. Contributing to the accident were the failure of the pilot to obtain a preflight weather briefing and his flight into known IMC.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
