Sedona, AZ, USA
N172FG
CESSNA 172
The pilot reported that she overflew the runway to check the windsock and established the wind favored runway 21. The pilot entered the traffic pattern and reported the airspeed on final was 68-70 knots and the flaps we set to 30°. The pilot reported that immediately after touchdown, the airplane veered to the left. The pilot stated full right rudder and brakes were applied to correct the situation; however, the airplane continued to veer, exited the paved runway surface, and flipped over. The pilot stated the wind at the time of the accident was 130° at 9 knots, with variable gusts. A witness observed the landing and stated it looked like the airplane encountered windshear while in ground effect, and the airplane landed on the nose gear. The nose landing gear fork collapsed during the accident sequence and the pilot opined that the nose landing gear fork showed evidence of pre-existing cracks and corrosion. NTSB Materials Laboratory evaluation of the nose landing gear fork showed no evidence of pre-existing cracks, corrosion, or indications of any pre-existing damage, such as cracking or corrosion. that would have contributed to premature fracture. The fracture features to the nose landing gear fork were indicative of fracture from overstress and likely the result of abnormal runway contact on landing. The evidence is consistent with the witness observations that the pilot lost pitch control of the airplane during landing in crosswind conditions, which resulted in a landing on the nose gear and its subsequent collapse.
On March 29, 2020, about 1142 mountain standard time, a Cessna 172, N172FG, was substantially damaged when it was involved in an accident at Sedona Airport (SEZ), Sedona, Arizona. The pilot and passenger were not injured. The airplane was operated as a Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 personal flight. The pilot departed Glendale, Arizona, with a planned destination of Sedona. The pilot approached Sedona from the east, overflew the airport, and observed that the windsock favored runway 21. The pilot reported the airspeed on final was “68-70 knots” and the flaps were set to 30°. The pilot reported that immediately after touchdown, just beyond the 1,000’ markers of runway 21, the airplane “took a violent 40° swing to the left.” The pilot stated full right rudder and brakes were applied to correct the situation; however, the airplane continued to veer and exited the paved runway surface. The pilot stated that after the airplane exited the runway, its nosewheel dug deep into the soft dirt, and the airplane flipped over. The pilot reported the wind at the time of the accident was 130° at 9 knots, with variable gusts. A witness stated the wind was “…very gusty and shifting” when the airplane landed. The witness stated that the airplane touched down on its nose gear, veered left, and nosed over after exiting the runway. Following the accident, the pilot reported that photographs of the nose gear fork “showed severe corrosion and cracks” where the nose landing gear failed. The pilot stated that the photographs were subsequently reviewed by a Federal Aviation Administration repair station, in California, and their representative stated the “part [nose gear fork] was severely compromised and unairworthy.” The pilot opined that these findings caused the airplane to swerve “off the runway.” The nose landing gear fork was sent to the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) materials laboratory for examination and inspection. The NTSB materials engineer who examined the components reported that the nose landing gear fork fracture features were indicative of fracture from overstress and that microscopic and macroscopic features were consistent with fracture from overstress in bending. The bending direction was upward, which would be consistent with the load profile expected during a landing of the downward-oriented fork. The NTSB materials engineer also reported that there were no indications of any pre-existing damage, such as cracking or corrosion, that would have contributed to premature fracture.
The pilot’s loss of pitch control while landing in crosswind conditions, which resulted in a collapsed nose gear and departure of the airplane from the runway.
Source: NTSB Aviation Accident Database
Aviation Accidents App
In-Depth Access to Aviation Accident Reports
